I made this map like two years ago. I think the overall layout is ok, there are probably some mayor position imbalances to fix though. What do you think?

I'm missing cliffs and tactical possibilities. It reminds me of C&C or WarCraft maps, because its so flat.

I'd guess it plays fine but its look does not attract me.

This map is like myself...looks better in the dark (low gamma) ^_^;

Well compared to the maps that are posted these days, it looks really bad. Back in the days, the overall quality of custom maps was not nerly as high as it is today, at least that's how I feel.

cant blame the symmetry anyways. looks as a good start anyways, and as Listoric sais, add some "cliffs and tactical possibilities" and it could be really nice

i think listoric and starparty mentioned everything, all i wanna add isthat the islands are very, very, small...
and 3 mineralpatches there are not enough i think.

This is kind of like a 1v1 version of The Hunters. The problem with The Hunters is that the high mineral patch count and lack of ramp/block favors protoss. If you reduce the strength of these advantages you have a cool 1v1 map.